How does FPC work?

2022-12-02

文章作者: dwyane3

Hello,
it is not uncommon for the emotions of the community to be stirred up by the decisions of the Fair Play Committee (FPC). This week we discussed with FPC members how to improve the quality of decision-making and I would like to share the results.

What have we changed?

BasketPulse deflections Simplified decision-making

FPC focus is on stopping cheating. Not on sanctioning teams if they are doing “not perfect” trade. So:

FPC vote Punish only when 100% sure that trade made is cheating.
FPC vote Revert only when a member thinks that this is cheating (for example, unbalanced trades and a member believes that these users could be somehow related or helping each other).
FPC vote Fair in all other cases (it is OK to make unbalanced trades if a member believes that these users are not related).

Basketpulse steals

What is considered cheating?

1. The trade must benefit both teams in some way (financially, roster-wise, etc.).
It is OK to trade an expensive good player for a worse and cheaper one. Such trades should not be abused.
2. Trades cannot be used to help another user. Each club must seek the maximum benefit for its team.
3. Any trade with a non-functional club (which is about to quit a game, or that is designed to get rid of "garbage players", or makes majority of trades that are illogical, etc.) is considered cheating.
4. Providing false information about a player in order to complete a trade (e.g. skills, experience, training information) is considered cheating.
5. Using game's bugs to gain an advantage is also considered cheating.

Basketpulse steals

We encourage discussion prior voting

We encouraged the FPC to create a separate channel on the FPC Discord channel for each report of unfair trading and to have their say before making a vote.

This will help to share information with each other and hopefully contribute to improving the quality of decisions.

Basketpulse steals

What do we expect from the community?

We want the community to help FPC make quality decisions.

When sending a trade offer, we recommend commenting in the trade message how the exchange is beneficial for both teams. This will help to evaluate the mutual benefit easier.

Important. FPC members volunteer and spend valuable personal time to help with the game and trades' evaluation. Please report suspicious trades only if you are sure that the teams are cheating.

回到首页

3.3 4.6 dwyane3

游戏新闻: How does FPC work?

-- 90 季 33 天

How does FPC work?

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+1

1.1 2.2 Duranciokas

Po blatu varkes sukamos ir viskas. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+10

john1-bot

Žaidimas tampa įdomus tik piniguočiams. Nusiperki mainų leveli ir gali daryti ką nori. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+11

1.1 2.1 Šabas

How dos FPC works ? oh well i could say pretty much the same as the main engine - there is some rules that no one understands , but mostly is random :D:D Nors man durančioko atsakymas labiau patiko . O iš tikro tai palikt tą FPC ramybėj, viskas čia gerai ir gerai jie dirba. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+1

1.1 1.1 fungtys

Reverting users could be "helping each other", means FPC is making it personal rather than targeting on "unbalanced trades".

Please reconsider as this rule of man encourages dictatorship which can damage the peace of the community. in the long run. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+1

1.1 2.1 Šabas

john1 visi norėjo kad visaks būtų kaip realybėj. Turi šaibų nusiperki klubą i klubą Juan Gómez de Liano gariūnų turguj medalį . Papostini viską į insta ir viskas u r the star baby -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+1

3.1 3.1 ekstrasensas

Suteptos rankos FPC pasitikėjimo nebesugrąžinsi.. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+4

john1-bot

buy credits and do what you want. if you can trade a 10 pot player for one 7 pot that might be useful to you after 10 seasons and thus reduce your weekly expenses by about 25k. the Chinese only help their relatives to rise higher to make their community stronger. This is circumventing the rules by supporting the game and promoting heresies. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0

1.1 2.1 Šabas

Ahhhhh there is nothing better in Friday evening than see how people arguing about the stuff they can't change on the game that suppose to be fun but it's not any more , and they get only negative on their personal choice ........boy oh boy do i like that .... ging to grab some popcorn and beer and tout " Fight fight" better than anny TV show or sports game ....... at least one good thing is not changing :D:D:D:D -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+2

2.1 3.2 fourkings

I agree with the view of fengtys. However, I believe that as long as FPC still has the right to vote to determine whether club transactions are illegal, we will never get rid of the "rule of man".

Since the western world has always advocated freedom and democracy, and has always liked the "separation of powers", I personally think that BP should also implement this management model. That is, the separation of "legislative power", "judicial power" and "executive power".

"Judicial power" is very easy to realize in the game, which is nothing more than regulating clubs with the game system. Under the existing rules, all transactions between clubs that do not violate the rules can be directly passed. The transaction violating the rules can be directly restricted by the system. This proactive management can completely avoid many problems and contradictions. For example, the disputes caused by voting to decide whether a club violates transactions, such as the "double standard" of treating different clubs in the face of the same type or similar transactions.

So where do the rules of the game come from? I think this is where FPC really comes into play. As Darius said, the ultimate goal of FPC is to establish a fair game order and punish those clubs that violate the rules. In this way, FPC can play the role of "House of Representatives" to study and formulate the rules of the game. When encountering the situation that the rules cannot handle, FPC needs to issue supplementary provisions to improve the existing rules. However, the transactions between clubs only need to be carried out in an orderly manner according to the rules. FPC exercises its legislative power without participating in the trial of specific cases, which can avoid human intervention to the greatest extent and achieve greater fairness.

As for the "executive power", it can be fully assumed by Darius. -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+6

2.1 3.2 fourkings

john1
I don't think it's strange that you have such a view because of the inherent concept. What do you think of my opinion? -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0

2.2 3.3 efkaefka

That's the theory, but the practice is quite different -- 90 季 33 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0

1.1 1.1 事出无常必有妖

The FPC needs to have clear rules. The same type of deal, some will go through, some will not go through.
Again, the same thing
Fair play committee
First, he has to be -- fair
Finally, I still oppose john1 on FPC. No matter how hard he tried, and no matter how personal his vote for the deal was, it was not fair that a Lithuanian with a British waistcoat should take a British FPC slot. -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+3

1.1 1.1 TRX001

Is john1 Lithuanian？interesting -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+2

Yes he just moved to UK to search better life -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0

1.1 1.1 事出无常必有妖

There is nothing wrong with moving to the UK in search of a better life, but taking up FPC slots in the UK does not make sense -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+2

Cosmos

Should we look up at everyones passport, to see wheres he from? -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+1

1.1 2.1 Šabas

i heard the rumors that his grandpa escaped from Lithuania during ww2 so . He grow up in UK speaks English and Lithuanian has both nationality's , consider him self as an English man but remember his roots . But who know maybe it's just rumors -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+1

由联盟志愿者或管理员隐藏的新闻信息 -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0

Y 1 fourkings

No matter what country John 1 lives in and what experience he has, I think he is no longer suitable for working in FPC. FPC's current executors are similar to the rights exercised by juries. But we all know that juries cannot be subjective. If a jury member is very hostile to a certain group, he is not suitable to play any role in the trial.

I quote his comments in this news without any personal feelings:

（The following paragraph is John 1's comment on the 33rd day of the 90 season. The original text is at the top of the news.）buy credits and do what you want. if you can trade a 10 pot player for one 7 pot that might be useful to you after 10 seasons and thus reduce your weekly expenses by about 25k. the Chinese only help their relatives to rise higher to make their community stronger. This is circumventing the rules by supporting the game and promoting heresies.（The above paragraph is John 1's comment on the 33rd day of the 90 season. The original text is above the news.）

I don't know what you think of John 1's remarks, but in my opinion, his almost instinctive judgment itself is hostile to the Chinese community -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+11

显示隐藏的回复: 19

3.1 3.1 ekstrasensas

Leave john1 alone! -- 90 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+2

BBBebrs

You clearly write here rules but do the oposite!

What is considered cheating states:
1) i need to know otherparty, make deal outside the needs of game.or inactive club.
I did not know the ither party. There is 0 reaso s for helping-we are nit even fro ine coutry! I received trade. It seema other party got short contracts and less spendig or whatever other side thinks. I was trying to find players for building future (just atarted).
As i see - other party is still active.
So there are 0 rules broken but still for some reason trade is canceled. Follow your rules!

2) dont try to justify yiur decision by fact that you encourage discussion.
3) in real world i coukd go for trial and even accuse you for calling be cheater which i find highly offensive. Here you have all the power so use it as grown ups or yiu ruin the game.

I dont know how else I can say that this is wring. I did not cone to thia game for these emotions. Try to admit mistake- i gavetoo big effort to be punished for nothing! For me the game has ended otherwise -- 93 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0

1.1 1.1 Jautrais

Trading Company, is that You? - is the legend back? -- 93 季 34 天

-- (翻译) (翻译 EN)

+0